Learn how factors like behavioural control, financial arrangements, and working relationships determine proper worker status and shield your business from compliance risks.
Patrick Evenden
Head of Thought Leadership, EMEA
Workday
Once leaders determine the work that needs to be done, the next question is how that work should be performed. While contract workers and employees can both bring valuable skills to an organisation, they serve different purposes within a workforce strategy.
The distinction extends beyond payroll or employment status. It affects how work is managed, how capabilities are developed and how organisations balance flexibility with long-term workforce investment. Four considerations are particularly important when deciding between employees or independent contractors.
The greatest distinction between employees and contract workers is the level of control an organisation has over how work is performed.
Employees typically work under the organisation's direction. Managers establish priorities, assign responsibilities, provide ongoing feedback and integrate employees into team processes and performance management.
Contract workers, by contrast, generally maintain greater independence over how they complete their work. Organisations define the expected outcomes, timelines and deliverables, but directing a contractor's day-to-day activities too closely may create worker classification and compliance risks.
Employees are usually hired to support ongoing business functions that evolve alongside organisational priorities. Their responsibilities often expand over time as business needs change.
Contract workers are mostly engaged to deliver a specific short term project, service or defined outcome. Whether implementing a technology platform, conducting a specialised assessment, or supporting a product launch, their engagement is tied to a clearly defined business need rather than an ongoing role.
Employees are paid through payroll, with taxes withheld and benefits provided according to company policies and applicable employment requirements. That means they are subject to financial deductions, such as Social Security tax, Medicare tax and income tax, as well as being protected by state and federal laws for minimum wage, overtime and employment discrimination.
Contract workers typically operate as independent businesses or sole proprietors. They invoice according to the terms of their agreement – whether by project, milestone, retainer or hourly rate – and are generally responsible for managing their own taxes, insurance, benefits and paid time off. That means businesses typically do not have any unemployment tax obligations for contractors either.
Employees become part of the organisation's long-term workforce. They develop institutional knowledge, build relationships across teams and often participate in learning, career development and internal mobility opportunities.
Contract workers may work closely with internal teams, but their engagement should remain tied to a defined scope of work rather than evolving into an ongoing employee-like relationship. The right workforce model begins with the work – not with the title attached to the worker.
When comparing independent contractors vs employees, it’s also important to recognise that these differences are more than administrative distinctions. Worker classification requirements vary by jurisdiction, and regulators generally evaluate the actual working relationship – not simply what's written in a contract.
Organisations should work closely with HR, legal, procurement and tax teams to ensure contractor engagements are structured appropriately and comply with applicable laws.
Nearly half of the average U.S. corporation’s workforce now consists of contract or other non-employee workers.
Contract workers are most effective when an organisation needs specialised expertise for a defined project or timeline. They enable leaders to quickly access capabilities, respond to emerging business needs and accelerate work without expanding permanent headcount.
Organisations are increasingly taking this approach. Deloitte estimates that nearly half of the average U.S. corporation's workforce now consists of contract or other non-employee workers, reflecting a broader shift toward more flexible workforce models.
For example, an organisation might engage a cybersecurity specialist to assess a new system, a consultant to support a transformation initiative or a creative professional to help launch a new product. In each case, the work has a clear scope, success can be measured against defined deliverables, and the organisation benefits from expertise without creating a long-term role.
Hiring an independent contractor can be especially valuable when organisations need to:
Access specialised expertise that isn't needed permanently
Increase capacity for a time-bound initiative
Accelerate work when internal teams are at capacity
Evaluate a new capability before making a long-term investment
Bring an outside perspective to a complex business challenge
At the same time, an immediate need for expertise doesn't automatically require an external hire. Before looking outside the organisation, leaders should consider whether employees already have adjacent skills or could gain them through targeted development or project-based work.
At Workday, internal gig opportunities have helped our employees build new capabilities through project-based experiences. Workday talent data also shows that employees who participate in internal gigs experience higher levels of internal mobility, proving organisations can uncover and deploy skills that already exist within their workforce.
Employees are generally the better choice when work requires sustained ownership, close collaboration or deep institutional knowledge.
Consider, for example, teams responsible for customer relationships, financial operations, core technology or people leadership. These functions depend not only on technical expertise but also on organisational context, cross-functional relationships and accountability that develops over time.
Hiring an employee often makes the most sense when the role:
Supports an ongoing business function rather than a defined project
Requires regular direction and collaboration with internal teams
Depends on deep knowledge of company processes, customers or culture
Involves access to sensitive systems or information
Represents a strategic capability the organisation wants to build over time
Building internal capability also strengthens organisational resilience. Over time, employees build organisational context, strengthen team collaboration and contribute to a stronger pipeline for leadership, internal mobility and future skills development.
The strongest workforce strategies recognise that both employees and contract workers have an important role to play. The challenge for leaders isn't choosing one model over the other; it's understanding which type of talent best aligns with the work and the organisation's long-term goals.
Rather than viewing employees and contract workers as competing options, leaders should see them as complementary parts of a modern workforce strategy.
The decision between a contract worker and an employee isn't about choosing one workforce model over another. It's about understanding the work that needs to be done and selecting the talent model best equipped to deliver it.
Organisations that make these decisions intentionally can respond more quickly to changing business needs, access specialised expertise when it matters most and continue building the internal capabilities that drive long-term success. Rather than viewing employees and contract workers as competing options, leaders should see them as complementary parts of a modern workforce strategy.
As business needs continue to evolve, the organisations best positioned for success will be those that match the right talent to the right work at the right time.
Feeling the strain of rapid market changes on your talent strategy? Develop a plan to unlock workforce potential with the right skills technology in this Workday Buyer's Guide.
Report
A gap between effort and impact is the real ROI problem. Discover the solution.